A great article on trying to pinpoint how exactly we can qualify certain books as ‘queer.’ This gets especially tricky with older titles where many of our contemporary markers of queerness are not legible (such as in Virginia Woolf’s work–I’ve had many people claim Orlando is not queer…umm?) or with books about younger people (such as tomboys) who may not identify as LGBTQ yet, or have even had queer experiences (i.e., Harriet the Spy!). It’s great to see this post critiquing an author who is trying to distance himself and his book from the category ‘gay.’ As I wrote in my comment, he’s accepting the stigma of the label gay and trying to reject the label, instead of questioning the stigma, which is the real problem here. Just because a book is queer, doesn’t mean a) it’s not a well-written book with literary merit and b) the book doesn’t also equally belong in other categories, such as young adult, or Canadian, or fantasy.
I have many of these same qualms about considering certain authors ‘Canadian’; if they’re residents of Canada but citizens of other countries can I count them as Canadian? Am I discounting writers’ backgrounds/homes in other parts of the world by calling them Canadian? What if they live in other parts of the world but write about Canada? What if they live in Canada but don’t write about the place or people from it? And how exactly do Indigenous authors fit into this equation, since it seems that the category ‘Canadian’ is at best irrelevant and at worst insulting and colonialist?
- My 2018 Year in Reading: Favourite Books of the Year, Most Memorable Character, Best Cover, and More!
- The 10 Best Queer Books of 2018 (that I read, at least)
- Not as Scary As I Hoped, but Cute Lesbians?: A Review of THE DARK BENEATH THE ICE by Amelinda Bérubé
- Delicious Italian Food and a Lack of Cohesion: A Review of Monica Meneghetti’s WHAT THE MOUTH WANTS
- “My bindi tells me where I’m from / my bindi reminds me of my mom”: A Review of Vivek Shraya’s Gender-Diverse Picture Book THE BOY & THE BINDI
- 4 of 5 stars to P.S. I Still Love You by Jenny Han goodreads.com/review/show/26… 46 minutes ago
- @r_bittner Yeah, very important point about the own voices representation. The two authors do have very different s… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 4 hours ago
- @r_bittner I am admittedly a romantic who leans more towards Albertalli than Silvera's style, so I can see that. I… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 5 hours ago
- @r_bittner What did they not like about it? 5 hours ago
- @r_bittner Yeah, I thought it was super cute but also realistic? I always find the teens in both of their books fee… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 5 hours ago